Danbooru

Unapproved fill/continuation pages from comics approval request thread

Posted under General

user 344162

Based on the rule (paraphrased):

Any page(s) from an otherwise approved sequential story (comic) pool generally should be approved.

Generally speaking we consider a comic to start and finish based on the naming/numbering scheme provided by the artist for the comic.

Example (Life of Maid):

メイドさんの日々1
メイドさんの日々2
メイドさんの日々3

That being said, it is possible for the artist to use a different naming/numbering scheme for the comic's title while confirming its place within the comic as a whole in the description.

Example (Touhou 4koma - (kiku hitomoji)):

東方・カラー4コマ漫画：Ｍａｓｔｅｒ ａｎｄ Ｐｕｐｉｌ
突貫特訓
東方・カラー4コマ漫画：指二本

The description states that page 突貫特訓 is part of 東方・カラー4コマ漫画

Be sure to check the description if something seems to be part of a comic but is not specifically titled as such.

What type of requests belong here:

  • Any request regarding pages from a comic that were not approved where other pages from the same comic were.

What types of requests do not belong here:

  • Any general appeal request. This is not the appeals thread nor are appeals its intent.
  • Any request regarding images from generic pools aka dat ass or clever. The rule was never intended for images in these pools.
  • Any request regarding fully unapproved comics. No one approved any part of the content so you will have to appeal it in the deletion appeal thread.
  • Any pages from a comic that were specifically deleted via a deletion request.
  • Any pages from comics where the only page(s) visible where uploaded by a contributor. They automatically bypass the mod queue and as such are not considered approved with regards to the aforementioned rule.
  • Requests from comic pools where multiple pages were uploaded at the same time but less then half of those pages were actually accepted.

Again this is not an appeal thread. The purpose of this thread is to bring to the attention of the mods any page(s)from comics that should by the aforementioned rule most likely have been approved.

That being said, this is not a get out of jail free card. Any page(s) from an otherwise approved comic that break TOS or are simply awful will very likely not be approved.

Lastly it is VERY important that any requests for pages of a comic to be approved are in fact directly related to the comic. Posts for missing pages of comics may very well be taken at face value so be very sure of what you are requesting.

If the title, content and description of the posts you want approved do not match the existing approved comic (even if the content is vaguely related) it is not part of the same comic and needs to be appealed as a whole on its own in the deletion appeal thread.

This thread is based on the discussion from forum #63133 and forum #39811

Updated by S1eth

Reply
user 344162

These are parts of sequential comics that seem to have been missed (all unapproved none deleted)

From pool #1546

post #888626
post #888627
post #891394
post #909964
post #915004
post #924332

From pool #3299

post #894845
post #894846
post #894847
post #894848

From pool #2493

post #895500
post #895501
post #895503
post #895504
post #895506
post #895508
post #895509
post #895511
post #895512
post #895513

From pool #3254

post #901466
post #901468
post #901469
post #901470

From pool #3362

post #901717
post #901718

From pool #3403 This has a single image approved (in comic format), so I am not sure where this sits rules wise.

post #907118
post #907119
post #907120
post #907122
post #907123
post #907125

From pool #3420

post #908593

From pool #834016

post #909440
post #909441
post #909442
post #909443
post #909445
post #909447
post #909448
post #909449

From pool #3432

post #918847

From pool #865

post #923463
post #923464
post #923466
post #923468

From pool #2557

post #927313
post #927314
post #927359
post #927360
post #927361
post #927298
post #927303
post #927304

From pool #1911

post #927875
post #927876
post #927877

From pool #2545

post #928450

From pool #2567

post #929377

Finally

pool #3598
pool #3458

Both have images(s) from the comic approved (drawings) but none of the comic format images approved. I listed them but I really have no idea where these would stand.

Reply
Saladofstones

Siegmund_200% said:
Best to avoid anything subjective and go strictly by artists titling and numbering.

If you look at his last 3 images on pixiv they are all 4koma and all similar theme but only two are titled as part of the 4koma. The other could be considered a "side story".

Unless the artist specifically says, "yes these are part of my current 4koma" we should leave them out.

It might be worth making a thread about though since comic pools have been getting looked at in general lately.

I think it means its part of the series its just not listed as such here.

Reply
user 344162

Anelaid said:
I think it means its part of the series its just not listed as such here.

Went back and checked the descriptions and they seem to imply (google translate and matching moon runes) that the post is part of the pool. I made an edit to the main post regarding that.

Reply
user 344162

Anelaid said:
The first two are definitely part of the same comic.

They all link to a comic called 例大祭お疲れ様でした！！ with that being written on the first image itself.

Unless there is something in the description that specifically states any image from that comic (例大祭お疲れ様でした！！) is actually part of the comic 霖之助漫画, all those images have to be considered to be from the comic they were titled as.

Reply
jxh2154

Heads up to people appealing: if you've got a 3 image pool where only one image was accepted, that's not quite in the spirit of the thread. This is most useful for one or two pages that fell through the cracks of an ongoing pool with a decent number of images. If only one of three got accepted, the pool probably isn't that great.

Reply
user 344162

jxh2154 said:
Heads up to people appealing: if you've got a 3 image pool where only one image was accepted, that's not quite in the spirit of the thread. This is most useful for one or two pages that fell through the cracks of an ongoing pool with a decent number of images. If only one of three got accepted, the pool probably isn't that great.

I will add that to the main topic. I thought that might be the case but needed official feedback on it.

For example I previously had a request involving a comic pool that was started by a contributor but the remaining images were not approved.

Log mentioned in the deletion appeal thread regarding an image appeal that contributor images =/= approved so I removed the request and added that to the do not list.

If you have anything else you feel should be mentioned please do so.

Reply
1 2