[REJECTED] Tag implication: outside_border -> border

create implication outside_border -> border

Link to implication

For something to be outside a border there needs to be a border.

EDIT: This tag implication is pending automatic rejection in 5 days.

EDIT: The tag implication outside_border -> border (forum #148287) has been rejected by @Hillside_Moose.

Not necessarily. The most common use of the tag does in fact not show any distinct border as we tag it on danbooru. See post #3167029, post #3166071 and in fact most of the posts under that tag.

nonamethanks said:

See post #3167029, post #3166071...

Both of which have the white border tag which implies border.

skylightcrystal said:

Both of which have the white border tag which implies border.

First, I'm not sure how many would call that a white border. Regardless of how others may have tagged it, at least for myself when I hear white border, I imagine a white outline with color on both sides.

Second, if one were to consider those as white borders (which I don't), then they would no longer be outside the border as they have not exceeded the edge of the border itself, which would be outside the image. Even if an the object in question were to encroach to the edge of the image, it could never be outside the border because that would be tagging something outside the image POV, something we don't typically do.

Finally, if one considers those not to be white borders (which I do), then the transition between color and white could be considered to be a quasi-border, and a foreground object extending past that border would then be outside the border.

Bonus Round:

Not all uses of outside border with white/black/color edges are fully enclosed on all sides (outside_border letterboxed).

BrokenEagle98 said:

First, I'm not sure how many would call that a white border. Regardless of how others may have tagged it, at least for myself when I hear white border, I imagine a white outline with color on both sides.

Tags such as outline and white outline has been used for that.

There are a handful of images tagged round_image outside_border for lack of a better tag, but generally speaking, I wouldn't call a round_image a border otherwise.

BrokenEagle98 said:

First, I'm not sure how many would call that a white border. Regardless of how others may have tagged it, at least for myself when I hear white border, I imagine a white outline with color on both sides.

Yeah I'm not sure I'd call those white borders either.

This tag implication is pending automatic rejection in 5 days.

The tag implication outside_border -> border (forum #148287) has been rejected by @Hillside_Moose.