Danbooru

alias rice_hat -> conical_hat

Posted under Tags

BUR #3108 has been rejected.

remove implication rice_hat -> hat
create alias rice_hat -> conical_hat
create implication conical_hat -> hat

This is a better name for the tag and more encompassing as it does not have to be for people cultivating rice, and has been worn in other cultures.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Asian_conical_hat

EDIT: This bulk update request is pending automatic rejection in 5 days.

EDIT: This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 60 days.

EDIT: The bulk update request #3108 (forum #170114) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.

Updated by DanbooruBot

I mean if you want to say that "conical" encompasses birthday hats, witch hats, etc, asian_conical_hat would alleviate that confusion, and be encompassing of all the different types of traditional conical hats of Asian cultures, such as the jingasa, hennin, and others which, if cultivated as their own tags may imply to the the new name of the tag which does not denote necessarily association with rice farming. I think being encompassing of those types of Asian conical hats is a good thing, as they're all of that type and may be clarified to their specific type

I would ask, is a jingasa a type of rice hat? My answer would be no, it's not, however I think all would agree it's a type of Asian conical hat, and this reflects the following tag count totals:

Post count for jingasa rice_hat: 6
Post count for jingasa -rice_hat: 39

Updated

Maybe an asian_conical_hat umbrella (heh) tag?
Tbh i don't really see the issue here. Unless i'm missing something, that kind of hat is called "rice hat" in english. Of course it's not used by only rice farmers, as for example baseball caps are only used by baseball players/fans.

Mysterious_Uploader said:

Maybe an asian_conical_hat umbrella (heh) tag?
Tbh i don't really see the issue here. Unless i'm missing something, that kind of hat is called "rice hat" in english. Of course it's not used by only rice farmers, as for example baseball caps are only used by baseball players/fans.

That's what I was going to make the request for originally put opted to remove _asian.

Considering that a jingasa is a type of [whatever we call this type of hat], shouldn't they receive the tag? If that's accepted it seems weird to me to call a jingasa a type of rice hat, but it's definitely a type of asian conical hat. I would think that we would want an implication to asian_conical_hat if the tag existed.

1