Posted under Tags
It has come to my attention that when tagging dangerous beast, sometimes it gets tagged alongside with mash_kyrielight_(cosplay) and fate/grand_order while sometimes it could lack one or both. And tag itself lacks implications making it somewhat unclear. So, i thought it would be worthwile to discuss this so it will be clear what to tag going forth.
Opinions?
If it stays as a gentag imo it should be treated like other common "meme" attires belonging to one character. See for example sugoi dekai. Having it share mash's tag as well makes it really hard to search for actual cosplays, since it overwhelms the mash_kyrielight_(cosplay) tag.
Otherwise if it's to be treated as cosplay it should be turned into a character tag, like all the other individual FGO costume tags.
+1 for treating it as a meme outfit not taggable as cosplay. It's at first glance a bit different in that it's often applied to other characters from the same franchise, but that's really just because Fate is so popular. Every piece of meme attire inevitably gets drawn with tons of Fate characters.
Not tagging dangerous_beast with fate/grand_order will make it easier to find dangerous_beast pictures that aren't Fate characters, as well as Mashu cosplays that aren't dangerous_beast.
7HS said:
+1 for treating it as a meme outfit not taggable as cosplay. It's at first glance a bit different in that it's often applied to other characters from the same franchise, but that's really just because Fate is so popular. Every piece of meme attire inevitably gets drawn with tons of Fate characters.
Not tagging dangerous_beast with fate/grand_order will make it easier to find dangerous_beast pictures that aren't Fate characters, as well as Mashu cosplays that aren't dangerous_beast.
But sugoi dekai and other "meme" outfits, like plugsuits, are almost always tagged with the copyright they originated from. Unless people aren't supposed to be doing that, and I couldn't find anything saying not to, I don't see why dangerous beast would be exempted from that.
I forgot about that, sorry. If that's what we do, that's what we do, though I think it would be optimal for usability purposes if we did not tag either the copyright or the character on any meme attire that originates from a specific character. Pointing back to those is what wiki pages are for.
Also, I personally don't think plugsuits are meme attire, just cosplays from a popular series that have been around for a long time and accumulated a lot of fanart. Similar cases with many posts are Shimakaze's outfit (this one is arguable, if anyone wanted to say her outfit is meme attire I wouldn't fight it,) Kaname Madoka's magical girl dress, and Saber's OG armor.
Another such outfit is piercing_bunny. Also trick or treatment.
Updated by nonamethanks
