Are we just assuming that 100% of posts in handjob gloves are in fact someone wearing gloves while giving a handjob, and not someone with bare hands giving a handjob while someone else present is wearing gloves?
Are we just assuming that 100% of posts in handjob gloves are in fact someone wearing gloves while giving a handjob, and not someone with bare hands giving a handjob while someone else present is wearing gloves?
This is more of an issue with our tag system in general (it's the same situation with colored eyewear/legwear/etc tags for non-solo pics), even more so in this case, because if those posts exist they're going to be impossible to find for normal users in any case, as glovejob would have to be applied to 99.99% of the posts under handjob gloves, which won't happen unless someone adopts the tag forever. As it stands it's just a redundant tag, because you would get more matching results searching for handjob gloves than for glovejob unless someone was constantly gardening the tag.
Are we just assuming that 100% of posts in handjob gloves are in fact someone wearing gloves while giving a handjob, and not someone with bare hands giving a handjob while someone else present is wearing gloves?
It seems rare but I quickly found one example of a handjob while wearing a glove on the other hand (post #1630051) and one giving a handjob to someone wearing gloves (post #4149339).
That's also my issue. "Glovejob" sounds like a glove used to jerk off a penis, it's begging to be used wrongly.
Personally I would go ahead with nuking glovejob and then rename cum in glove -> glovejob. Cum in glove doesn't sound like it's being used as a handjob to me, just that there's cum inside a glove.
Personally I would go ahead with nuking glovejob and then rename cum in glove -> glovejob. Cum in glove doesn't sound like it's being used as a handjob to me, just that there's cum inside a glove.
That sounds like the better solution to me. I've updated the BUR. It's also consistent with how it was used in the past before being changed by the same user who populated the current version (1, 2, 3).
Dick-inside-glove is exactly what glovejob used to be, until @clamz redefined it today to mean gloved handjob and created cum in glove for what glovejob used to be.
I don't mind having a gloved handjob tag as long as someone actually goes through gloves handjob and populates it. Otherwise there's not much point, anyone who wants this will have to search gloves handjob anyway or they'll miss most of the results.
Dick-inside-glove is exactly what glovejob used to be, until @clamz redefined it today to mean gloved handjob and created cum in glove for what glovejob used to be.
I don't mind having a gloved handjob tag as long as someone actually goes through gloves handjob and populates it. Otherwise there's not much point, anyone who wants this will have to search gloves handjob anyway or they'll miss most of the results.
Changed the BUR to alias cum_in_glove to penis_in_glove.
As the user that made the changes to the tags in the first place, I apologize for the confusion and if I overstepped my boundaries. My thinking was that a tag (either glovejob or something related like gloved_handjob) used specifically for scenarios where someone is wearing gloves and giving a handjob would be useful as it would match up directly with the 手袋コキ tag on Pixiv, and using the gloves + handjob tags doesn't always bring up a gloved handjob.
However, I realize that the vast majority of times you can get a gloved handjob combining the gloves + handjob tag anyways, and that it would be an arduous task to go through years of pictures to add a new tag. I will have the time in the next day or two to take this on if you like, but if you feel a tag specific for gloved handjobs is redundant, I have no objection at all. I will hold off on adding it to any other pictures for the time being.