Question about the error tag

I know the general rule is "tag what you see, not what you know" but does this apply to the error tag and related tags? E.g. should images of J. Geil, who really does have two right hands, get the error and wrong_hand tags?

In this specific case it isn't an error, because the error would be if the character had a left hand I guess. The wiki for the character does say not to tag it as error so..

Bicorn said:

I know the general rule is "tag what you see, not what you know" but does this apply to the error tag and related tags? E.g. should images of J. Geil, who really does have two right hands, get the error and wrong_hand tags?

He shouldn't get either, but we can't really help if taggers unfamiliar with the character tag his images such; those will have to be gardened out if it happens.

Should be rare though, so no big deal.

Astolfo said:

The wiki for the character does say not to tag it as error so..

It does, but I felt I should find what the consensus on the matter is.

I agree with the others, if something is canonically in some way then it cannot be an error. The error tag should be reserved to errors in respect to the source material, not real life.