Holding implications and cleanup

BUR #7168 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

Missing implications first. Most holding_* tags have such implications, they help with people forgetting to tag holding or the object being held. Most of the tags with missing implications have posts with missing tags.

Missing implications part 1, tags with 100+ posts.

BUR #7169 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

Missing implications part 2, tags with 75-99 posts.

BUR #7170 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

Missing implications part 3, tags with 50-75 posts.

More requests coming probably tomorrow.

BUR #7179 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

remove implication holding_cape -> holding
create implication holding_cape -> holding_clothes
remove implication holding_ring -> holding
create implication holding_ring -> holding_jewelry
remove implication holding_swimsuit -> holding
create implication holding_swimsuit -> holding_clothes
remove implication holding_candy_cane -> holding
create implication holding_candy_cane -> holding_candy

Fixing wrong implication hierarchy.

BUR #7181 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create alias holding_gemstone -> holding_gem
create implication holding_gem -> holding
create implication holding_gem -> gem
create alias holding_purse -> holding_bag

Gemstone is aliased to gem and purse to handbag, so let's rename these accordingly.

Do we really need a separate tag for holding handbags?

Some observations from a first glance (didn't check them all yet):

• as was pointed out by evazion in forum #176784, holding naginata, holding spear and holding lance should just be aliased to holding polearm
• we have holding railing and hand_on_railing. I think these tags can be aliased, with the latter being the main one. It would also remove the issue that you don't really "hold" a railing, at best you "hold on to"
• we have holding sparkler and holding fireworks. We might as well alias them and keep the latter
• the luggage tag looks like a bad tag to me. Why don't tags like rolling_suitcase imply it? I don't like creating an implication for holding luggage if our definition of the main tag is so generic and smells of wikipedia copypaste. This deserves its own thread
• echoing what evazion said in forum #170125, holding bikini tags should just be all aliased to holding swimsuit

Unbreakable said:

Do we really need a separate tag for holding handbags?

purse holding_bag has more relevant results than holding purse, so it probably should just be aliased to the main tag.

Unbreakable said:

Do we really need a separate tag for holding handbags?

I think it can be useful, there are 6347 posts for holding bag vs. 91 for holding purse. There are many low count holding_* tags, I think they are especially useful for regular users so they don't have to use all two tags just for that.

BUR #7182 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

mass update unaliased:holding_bikini_bottom -> holding_swimsuit -holding_bikini_bottom
create alias holding_playing_card -> holding_card

As per above.
Added holding_playing_card -> holding_card.

What to do with:

• holding_necktie? Most are either attached to the "holder" or someone else, but some are removed.
• holding_up? Most are just holding something but many miss the tag. I'd say manually empty it.
• holding_brush? Still a terrible tag name, as noted in forum #170125. (Related, brush is equally terrible but that's worth it's own thread)

There are several things in holding plant that I'd question whether they warrant the plant tag - quite a few of them are holding bits of plants like post #4565708 which I wouldn't give the plant tag.

I think holding playing card should be bulk updated into holding card and playing card. There's no need for a separate tag.

skylightcrystal said:

There are several things in holding plant that I'd question whether they warrant the plant tag - quite a few of them are holding bits of plants like post #4565708 which I wouldn't give the plant tag.

I think holding playing card should be bulk updated into holding card and playing card. There's no need for a separate tag.

Thanks for the input.
Edited BUR #7168 to only implicate holding_plant -> holding, manually added the tags to holding_playing_card and added alias to holding_card to BUR #7182.

The bulk update request #7168 (forum #196494) has been approved by @nonamethanks.

The bulk update request #7169 (forum #196495) has been approved by @nonamethanks.

The bulk update request #7170 (forum #196496) has been approved by @nonamethanks.

The bulk update request #7179 (forum #196522) has been approved by @nonamethanks.

The bulk update request #7181 (forum #196524) has been approved by @nonamethanks.

The bulk update request #7182 (forum #196530) has been approved by @nonamethanks.

Some notes:

• Removed the holding hair ornament implication. There's an argument to be made here for hair ornament removed posts to be mutually exclusive with hair ornament, which is really for worn hair ornaments
• Removed holding luggage for the point stated in my previous post. We don't have a real definition for luggage so we should get one first
• Removed the holding purse hierarchy and changed it to an alias to holding bag. If we don't distingush holding backpack either then there's no point in giving such a small tag a special treatment when most users seem fine just tagging it with holding bag

The bulk update request #7182 (forum #196530) has been approved by @nonamethanks.