@Hankpropaniac57: BUR #23475 has been rejected. create alias...

Hankpropaniac57
2024-02-17T16:09:51-05:00

BUR #23475 has been rejected.

Show

create alias adipocere_(vocaloid) -> adipocere_(iyowa)
create alias urapocere_(vocaloid) -> urapocere_(iyowa)
create alias akairo_ga_kowai_(vocaloid) -> akairo_ga_kowai_(iyowa)
create alias akuma_!_(synthesizer_v) -> akuma_!_(iyowa)
create alias angel_care_(vocaloid) -> angel_care_(iyowa)
create alias apricot_(vocaloid) -> apricot_(iyowa)
create alias babel_(utau) -> babel_(iyowa)
create alias chikyuu_no_ura_(cevio) -> chikyuu_no_ura_(iyowa)
create alias clover_knight_(vocaloid) -> clover_knight_(iyowa)
create alias daijoyuu-san_(synthesizer_v) -> daijoyuu-san_(iyowa)
create alias dear_my_witchcraft_(vocaloid) -> dear_my_witchcraft_(iyowa)
create alias golden_number_(vocaloid) -> ougonsuu_(iyowa)
create alias heaven's_bug_(vocaloid) -> heaven's_bug_(iyowa)
create alias hoho_ga_kawaku_made_(vocaloid) -> hoho_ga_kawaku_made_(iyowa)
create alias hoshoku_hihoshoku_(vocaloid) -> hoshoku_hihoshoku_(iyowa)
create alias imawanokiwa_(vocaloid) -> imawanokiwa_(iyowa)
create alias isei_ni_ikou_ne_(cevio) -> isei_ni_ikou_ne_(iyowa)
create alias issen_kounen_(vocaloid) -> issen_kounen_(iyowa)
create alias kyu-kurarin_(cevio) -> kyu-kurarin_(iyowa)
create alias last_journey_(vocaloid) -> last_journey_(iyowa)
create alias mercy_killing_(vocaloid) -> mercy_killing_(iyowa)
create alias muko_no_anata_(vocaloid) -> muko_no_anata_(iyowa)
create alias netsu_ijou_(utau) -> netsu_ijou_(iyowa)
create alias otome_wo_odore_(vocaloid) -> otome_wo_odore_(iyowa)
create alias over!_(vocaloid) -> over!_(iyowa)
create alias pajamy_(vocaloid) -> pajamy_(iyowa)
create alias potpourri-san_(vocaloid) -> potpourri-san_(iyowa)
create alias sayonara_jackpot_(vocaloid) -> sayonara_jackpot_(iyowa)
create alias shuumatsu_no_otenki_(vocaloid) -> shuumatsu_no_otenki_(iyowa)
create alias suishitai_ni_modoranaide_(vocaloid) -> suishitai_ni_modoranaide_(iyowa)
create alias tabun_owari_(vocaloid) -> tabun_owari_(iyowa)
create alias warera_wa_hare_(vocaloid) -> warera_wa_hare_(iyowa)
create alias watashi_wa_kinki_(vocaloid) -> watashi_wa_kinki_(iyowa)
create alias yumemiru_uroko_(voisona) -> yumemiru_uroko_(iyowa)

I'm proposing a change to how Vocaloid (and other voice synth engine) songs are qualified, choosing instead to use the name of the artist as a qualifier. This would allow someone to search *_([artist name]) and find art for all of that artist's songs collected together. The name of the artist who made the song also serves as a more unique qualifier. This is useful when songs use ambiguous or even identical names, as in the case of +-0 (vocaloid), where 143 songs with the same name were made for a music submission festival.

A counterargument might be that a *_(vocaloid) wildcard search is more useful to have when someone would like to search for song fanart in general, but the tags are capped at 100, and it would also catch unrelated art of characters who use their engine as their qualifier. It also wouldn't catch songs made with other engines, of which there are many, and it's not as if many Vocaloid producers are engine loyalists. In the case of Iyowa, he's used voicebanks from five different engines for his music. I'd like to do this with Iyowa at least, because it would be useful to be able to search for fanart of all of his songs at once.

An alternative to this would be to create umbrella tags for music producers or music projects, of which there are already a few (Inabakumori, Evillious Nendaiki). I submitted this BUR to see if this would be a desirable change to how songs on Danbooru are tagged. If not, an umbrella is fine too.

I also threw in an alias for Golden Number, from its English to Japanese name. I'll re-submit that one independently if this fails, just to fix the name.