Danbooru

Sailor Moon BUR

Posted under Tags

BUR #26824 has been approved by @nonamethanks.

create implication bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon_(first_season) -> bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon
create implication bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon_r -> bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon
create implication bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon_s -> bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon
create implication bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon_supers -> bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon
create implication bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon_stars -> bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon
create implication bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon_another_story -> bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon
create implication pretty_guardian_sailor_moon -> bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon
create implication sailor_moon_musical -> bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon
create alias moon_stick -> moon_stick_(sailor_moon)

Expanding on the franchise by making copyright tags for each of the seasons, encompassing any exclusive characters, events, items and such for each one. I did a lot of tag gardening to populate the season tags, as well as tightening up the official artists and style parodies, and making tags for the various brooches and tools that Sailor Moon uses. It is hard to keep the official artists straight since their styles are very similar, so the history of who worked on the 90s anime can get understandably confusing.

The Moon Stick alias is because some images were mistakenly tagged with it when crescent wand should have been used instead.

Blank_User said:

BUR #26835 has been rejected.

create alias bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon -> bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon_(series)
remove alias bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon -> bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon_(series)
create alias bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon_(first_season) -> bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon
remove alias bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon_(first_season) -> bishoujo_senshi_sailor_moon

I think we should use the *_(series) convention for this. If this BUR passes, then the previous BUR should be updated accordingly.

This seems unnecessary to me. Wouldn't it be a lot more confusing to have the title for the series as tag for a specific season? Especially if we change it now after years of use for a hotswapping between the series tag and the season tag.

nonamethanks said:

This seems unnecessary to me. Wouldn't it be a lot more confusing to have the title for the series as tag for a specific season? Especially if we change it now after years of use for a hotswapping between the series tag and the season tag.

That's why I requested the bishoujo senshi sailor moon (first season) tag imply bishoujo senshi sailor moon, since the regular copytag has pretty much been established as the series' overall umbrella tag. Changing this would definitely cause a lot of confusion.

The reason I made the individual season tags was because I saw how other series have separate seasons identified with tags of their own, yet for some reason BSSM did not despite being well known for having five seasons. Due to this, it felt like a necessity to refer to the first season with the qualifier, rather than the series' umbrella tag. It's similar to how a series that uses numbers don't REALLY have an entry with the number 1, like Final Fantasy I, Wild Arms 1, Tokimeki Memorial 1 and so on, but they exist for convenience. That was the logic I was using when I made the BSSM First Season copytag.

1