should there be a way to categorize "naked school attendance"?

Posted under General

as a fan of the zenra tag, i've noticed that going to school naked is a particularly popular subgenre within it. you can find hundreds of images specifically focused on that on pixiv and twitter by searching for 全裸登校. but while a lot of images fall under that context, they often have very different situations.
a lot of them depict characters on their way to school rather than being at school, and will show them somewhere like inside a train or on a city street. even when they're at school, they can be in different parts of it like a classroom or the gym. even the """outfits""" they wear can vary, with some opting to have the characters only wear things like neck ribbons and socks and shoes, others wearing only part of a school uniform, and some going full nude. and the actual reason for attending naked can vary too, from heat to more commonly a rule or change in common sense

basically there's a lot of things that fall under this contextual umbrella and i don't think a simple search for something like zenra classroom can cover even close to all of it, so i was just wondering if a new tag or pool or something would be appropriate.
i understand the potential for ambiguity here, because there's no doubt a ton of 'naked in a classroom' images and other similar things, but most of the time these images are just blatantly tagged somewhere at the source as 全裸登校 or something similar, and when they aren't, then i don't think it's too hard to figure out the context of the image in the same way you would for any other tag that relies on context like zenra or change_in_common_sense. and there's also the potential for the characters to be upset and embarrassed about the situation, so i don't think it all falls under simple 'casual nudity' either.

what do you all think?

If you want, you can get started by using a pool or favgroup to gather these posts, so everyone can judge what does or doesn't belong and easily add the tag on afterwards.

As for a tag, I'll throw out a suggestion: naked_school_uniform. It sounds stupid, but it gets the point across. It also doesn't lock the tag to only a school setting and covers commutes or after school activities.

ok, i looked through as many images as possible and made favgroup #40633, hopefully that conveys this concept well enough.
i will admit that i interpreted it a little loosely and added stuff like half naked uniforms (topless/bottomless), as well as things like sports meets and school festivals that probably don't immediately convey the concept as well as other images would, but it's all ultimately related to attending school naked so i felt it all fit. i'd get wanting to be a little more strict with it though, especially when there are probably many more images that fall under this category i just can't see yet because my account is only member level lol.

i think naked_school_uniform could work, especially when i was a little unsure about adding some of the images that focused on sex more than anything else, but i don't know if that could still work with things like the aforementioned sports and festival stuff. like post #8803898 is part of a naked school series according to the commentary, but its a festival setting and has reverse bunnysuits instead of a naked uniform. but like i said a naked_school_attendance tag doesn't feel perfect either when we have stuff like post #2146873, which i think is very much part of this concept considering it's a cg from an entry in an entire naked school visual novel series, but just looking at it doesn't really convey the actual attendance part.

i'm still more in favor of naked_school_attendance, but if you guys have any other ideas then feel free to share

Naked school uniform sounds like something in the vein of naked apron which isn't what I think @zenzeni99 mean to see. So I'd say naked school attendance makes more sense.

Btw, does this concept also apply to situation where a school girl is having breakfast at home as preparation before going to school? The location is not at school or the way to school but it's a part of the going to school process. Then there's the "going home from school" situation which "school attendance" doesn't exactly apply but I think this is one of those cases where we just have to accept that the concept is bigger than the words representing it.

well after uploading a few more images in this subgenre i still believe a tag is warranted but i know it's tough to get the right wording. i don't know how literal or loosely a more contextual tag generally should be interpreted here but personally i feel that a simple naked_school_attendance would work just fine as long as we're willing to accept aforementioned things like not completely naked uniforms, and various situations like a festival or returning home.

if, here on danbooru, that tag is supposed to be used for hypnosis stuff, then it could apply to various instances of what this tag would be, but it often wouldn't.
like post #8943311 and the others in the series are explicitly contextualized with a local rule. it's a change from our common sense, but for those characters, it really is just normal, nothing is changed for them, no hypnosis is involved. so i don't think change_in_common_sense is enough to cover all of this. not to mention other pics i've mentioned where the characters are embarrassed, where if they were hypnotized there's a good chance they wouldn't be at all

definitelysleeping said:

Since you've gone with naked_school_attendance for now, I would also ask whether this includes stuff like Hagakure Toru, who is indeed attending nude, but is also theoretically invisible? Next, would nude modeling for art classes count when the model is also a student?

Toru does actually wear a school uniform though. She's only (almost) nude when in her hero uniform. I would personally say nude modeling doesn't really count for the purposes of this tag.

Ylimegirl said:

Toru does actually wear a school uniform though. She's only (almost) nude when in her hero uniform. I would personally say nude modeling doesn't really count for the purposes of this tag.

There are some examples of Toru wearing her hero "uniform" in a school setting when everyone else isn't wearing theirs, but I'd still be hesitant to include those because it doesn't feel like they really fit the vibe of the tag if no one else can see the "nude student", or at least Toru assumed they couldn't.

I do agree about not including nude modeling. Unless the whole class is also nude, it shouldn't matter if the model is a student or not.

Hillside_Moose said:

If you check Geso Smith's nudist slice-of-life series from post #6747831 onward, that would be the best examples for the vibe the naked_school_attendance tag is going for. It covers before school, during school, and after school.

Basically, instead of a normal school uniform, nudity becomes the "uniform".

This. Kinda like an emperor’s new clothes situation—everyone just agrees this is what school attendance entails.

1 2