Meaningless Sleeveless Turtlenecks

BUR #39074 has been rejected.

deprecate sleeveless_turtleneck
deprecate sleeveless_turtleneck_leotard
deprecate sleeveless_turtleneck_dress
deprecate sleeveless_turtleneck_sweater
deprecate sleeveless_turtleneck_bodysuit
nuke sleeveless_turtleneck
nuke sleeveless_turtleneck_leotard
nuke sleeveless_turtleneck_dress
nuke sleeveless_turtleneck_sweater
nuke sleeveless_turtleneck_bodysuit

I believe sleeveless and turtleneck describe the main attire so the first one makes no sense to have, and since we should already have sleeveless_attire and turtleneck_attire, these are unnecessary and redundant.

sleeveless_turtleneck is a distinct look and I think it makes sense to retain as a combo tag.

BUR #39075 has been rejected.

deprecate sleeveless_turtleneck
deprecate sleeveless_turtleneck_leotard
deprecate sleeveless_turtleneck_dress
deprecate sleeveless_turtleneck_sweater
deprecate sleeveless_turtleneck_bodysuit
mass update sleeveless_turtleneck -> -sleeveless_turtleneck
mass update sleeveless_turtleneck_leotard -> -sleeveless_turtleneck_leotard
mass update sleeveless_turtleneck_dress -> -sleeveless_turtleneck_dress
mass update sleeveless_turtleneck_sweater -> -sleeveless_turtleneck_sweater
mass update sleeveless_turtleneck_bodysuit -> -sleeveless_turtleneck_bodysuit

Same reason as above but changing the nuke to update as mentioned that the tags do not imply anything.

The bulk update request #39074 (forum #343356) has been rejected by @zaregoto.

Shinjidude said:

sleeveless_turtleneck is a distinct look and I think it makes sense to retain as a combo tag.

Every potential combo is a "distinct look". long-sleeved_crop_tops, denim_short_shorts, and toeless_sneakers are all unique, but if we start tagging these things then suddenly we also need long-sleeved_v-neck and long-sleeved_off-shoulder_shirt, denim_capri_pants and denim_miniskirt, toeless_thigh_boots and toeless_high_heels, and so on. We don't need hundreds of these tags when combining the base ones works just fine.

I think I probably prefer to just deprecate and not nuke, since there's a nonzero chance people tag only sleeveless turtleneck and forget to actually tag sweater, which is probably the majority of the tag.

BUR #39077 has been rejected.

Updated the bur so that while removing the tag, add the already existing sensible tags.

The bulk update request #39075 (forum #343358) has been rejected by @zaregoto.

Third time's the charm.

This is also a not-so-uncommon top worn by characters such as Yuffie Kisaragi and Kouzuki Kallen and shouldn't require two tags to search for.

You forgot sleeveless leotard, which incidentally is small compared to sleeveless turtleneck leotard for some reason.

If we go this route, we should also consider nuking tank_top and camisole as they are also sleeveless shirts with unique shapes (which I obviously think is a bad idea).

hasu_no_kougeki said:

You forgot sleeveless leotard, which incidentally is small compared to sleeveless turtleneck leotard for some reason.

That tag should be nuked; leotards are sleeveless by default. I've made a BUR for that in topic #31184.

Bump for some more discussion.

I agree with Shinjidude, especially as a restricted pleb with two tags per search as I feel especially inclined to not have to search for any more tags than I have to when looking for a specific look ie the sleeveless turtleneck.
Plus it is indeed a distinct look from a regular turtleneck, unlike the aforementioned sleeveless leotard which is actually redundant and meaningless.

This bulk update request is pending automatic rejection in 5 days.

This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 45 days.

The bulk update request #39077 (forum #343378) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.

BUR #42661 has been rejected.

mass update sleeveless_turtleneck_dress -> sleeveless_turtleneck turtleneck_dress
mass update sleeveless_turtleneck_bodysuit -> sleeveless_turtleneck turtleneck_bodysuit
mass update sleeveless_turtleneck_leotard -> turtleneck_leotard

Since topic #32136 is practically set to deprecate these tags, I'm hoping to address the other problem that I noticed with these tags - namely, that most of the tagged posts lack the expected subset tags. I've gone through sleeveless turtleneck sweater and fixed all of the posts (and removed a few that don't even qualify for the tag to be deprecated), but the others have too many posts for such a manual approach to be feasible, thus the update BUR that I'm proposing.

You can add multiple tags at a time in a mass update yknow. This BUR could be 3 lines.