Posted under Tags
BUR #40415 is pending approval.
create implication worlds -> porter_robinson_(copyright)
create implication nurture -> porter_robinson_(copyright)
create implication smile!_:d -> porter_robinson_(copyright)
These are all copyrights related to Porter Robinson, so they should each implicate Porter Robinson as a general copyright.
(Copyright) is a bad qualifier, I feel it'd be better to do Porter Robinson and Porter Robinson (person) (if a chartag is ever needed), like Chappell Roan/Chappell Roan (person), MF Doom/MF Doom (person), etc.
Also Worlds and Nurture should probably be qualified. They're normal English words.
Confetto said:
(Copyright) is a bad qualifier, I feel it'd be better to do Porter Robinson and Porter Robinson (person) (if a chartag is ever needed), like Chappell Roan/Chappell Roan (person), MF Doom/MF Doom (person), etc.
Also Worlds and Nurture should probably be qualified.
Agreed. We have Lady Gaga (copyright) and Beyonce (copyright) though...
GranAutismo said:
Agreed. We have Lady Gaga (copyright) and Beyonce (copyright) though...
Those two are older, I'm pretty sure, and no one's ever bothered trying to do anything about them. Honestly they're kind of especially odd given we could always use Stefani Germanotta and Beyonce Knowles as the chartags.
Individual musicians that build a sort of brand and get referenced beyond the person themselves can be a pain in general, a lot of them are all over the place. There's also Ado (utaite) and Camellia (musician) but those are qualified for ambiguity.
personally I don't find these copyright tags valuable. also, what about something like shelter?
edit: Separate thread by same person in topic #31666; topics also have the "Request alias/implication" button so you can add multiple BURs to one topic
GranAutismo said:
Agreed. We have Lady Gaga (copyright) and Beyonce (copyright) though...
Lady Gaga is who I looked at initially for this. Was trying to think of anyone in said situation, but if there's no general ruling he might fall under what Confetto suggested.
Confetto said:
Also Worlds and Nurture should probably be qualified. They're normal English words.
Definitely would be better, I was tired doing most of this last night, so apologies if anything submitted related to this is weird.
LQ said:
personally I don't find these copyright tags valuable. also, what about something like shelter?
I mean, we have plenty of other album copytags, including many with implications, so it's not like it's egregious even if it's a bit unnecessary to make implications for 1 post tags.
