@Damian0358: > WRS said: > > The ridiculous line of...

Damian0358
2025-09-23T10:05:34-04:00

WRS said:

The ridiculous line of reasoning that would justify this would also potentially churn out the horror of tagging what is literally just alternative colouring for an otherwise established skin, which some old gacha games like Honkai Impact 3rd have[1].

[1]: Have as in, they have skins that are just a palette swap. I don't know of any Danbooru posts of them but I at least know none of them have separate tagging because so help me Fumimi I would BUR those out of existence.

Unfortunately, if you have an issue with that, then you're not going to like the decision reached in topic #26181.

Ylimegirl said:

Some of these collaboration outfits are real popular for fanart of FGO specifically (probably because fanart of FGO itself is real popular, plus servants aren't usually portrayed in contemporary casual clothing in-game). Miyamoto Musashi (FGO x Pasela Resorts) even later got a figure for it. It also feels weird to tag something like post #3352139 with Lawson.

Yeah, this goes back to what I said in my first post, that the reason why Genshin made its collab costume tags was moreso because they became real popular in fanart. However, as I said that, I also pointed out using "popularity" as a measure on whether to make a tag requires nuance. As I explained in topic #26611, the reason why maximalist tagging wins out discursively is because it is incredibly simple - see design, tag it as its own thing, move on - because anything other than maximalist tagging requires the inconsistent application of boundaries, which may result in tags not being made (which leads to debates later on why something wasn't tagged), while maximalist tagging always ensures tags get made.

Esperantisto said:

I feel like the list in wikis of collaborated copyrights needs to be updated first because there's no way Lawson only has 7 of them.

A wiki getting outdated? Say it ain't so!

Honestly, it's probably more practical to list the collab in the collaber's wiki and not the collabee's, because Lawson and similar convenience stores do way too many of them, which is incidentally part of why making collab costume chartags is such a can of worms. Like, again, this could potentially result in Peanuts costume tags. SNOOPY COSTUME TAGS!