fingernail_polish -> nail_polish
just in case, unless fingernail polish makes more sense
Updated
Posted under General
fingernail_polish -> nail_polish
just in case, unless fingernail polish makes more sense
Updated
Given that it can be used on fingernails and toenails, the more general nail_polish tag would be better.
There is also a toenail_polish tag, I think this one should be kept to distinguish between images where it is showing fingernail polish (more common) and toenail polish (less common). The tag also should probably also implicate nail_polish.
Right, I remember now
I'd rather not have to rely on a tag search where the toes could be present but nail_polish on them isn't it.
I would be against implications here.
Keeping (finger)nail_polish and toenail_polish separate allows to search for both at the same time, which is nice I think.
The other possibility—moving nail_polish to fingernail_polish, then implicating both fingernail_polish and toenail_polish to nail_polish, is overkill for the few toenail_polish posts it's made for. nail_polish and fingernail_polish searches would be nearly identical, making the extra tag redundant on all these posts (yet we did that for feet_in_water -> soaking_feet, which IMO was a bad move).
Also, with that said I'm not sure if an alias between fingernail_polish and nail_polish would help.
I'd think the current situation is fine, while not the most intuitive.
Updated
fingernail and toenail polish will stay separate tags.
As for implicating to a common nail_polish, well either 1) we do that 2) we get rid of nail_polish or 3) nail_polish only applies to the cosmetic in its container, not being applies to any digits. It serves no other purpose with the two nail polish tags.
The nail_polish wiki states the tag applies for both finger and toe nail polish. There exists no images under fingernail_polish. toenail_polish is underrepresented, because images are more frequently only tagged nail_polish.
Ah, didn't see fingernail_polish wasn't used. Well we could either start using it, or just leave the status quo.
jxh2154 said:
3) nail_polish only applies to the cosmetic in its container, not being applies to any digits.
There is the nail_polish_bottle tag being used for that.
^
I made 'bottle' because it was more obvious and because the polish would refer to the liquid 'on or in' something.
As for the wiki on nail_polish, I went with what the majority of the images were. Would ppl be comfortable adding additional text of "finger"?