I'd like some feedback on these if possible:
post #3656081 and children posts.
post #3637156 single unapproved animation out of the entire set.
post #3547107 well animated.
Posted under General
I'd like some feedback on these if possible:
post #3656081 and children posts.
post #3637156 single unapproved animation out of the entire set.
post #3547107 well animated.
727272 said:
I just had 5 uploads not be approved, and it some of them baffle me as to why the weren't approved.
I really don't understand why this was deleted. The same artist has over 30 uploads in the exact same style.
Likewise for this. It's literally the next entry in a series of Touhou characters. You can check the rest out at the artists page.
This just seems incredibly arbitrary and that I'm wasting my time by attempting to upload.
The first of those is very basic, and more so than any of the active artwork by that artist, both regarding shading and detail. It's also worth mentioning that only 9 of that artist's works were approved by anyone other than Himegami Akane, and post #2702403 is typical of those posts' standard. Not even in the same league as the one you uploaded.
As for the second one... Bear in mind that pictures are judged individually. Leeway for approval of weaker parts of a series does exist, but is really for when one picture is necessary to fully appreciate another, usually when they tell some kind of story. This is clearly not the case here.
Looking then at the actual art in question, aside from the large amount of colour spill, I'm struggling to make out the anatomy under that dress. I just don't see how it all comes together without some sort of optical illusion (or detached leg)... Oh, and some of those fingers are really dodgy too. While some of the artist's other work is far from ideal (the left leg of post #1911407 is definitely suffering some sort of problem), they aren't as eggregious as post #3662929.
Konan-Beatrice said:
post #3661406
post #3661397
post #3660514
post #3661658
post #3660472
post #3660436
post #3660459
post #3642672
post #2670682
post #3648569
post #2671180
post #2670580
post #2605935
post #2605532
post #2605482
post #2605445
post #2599158
Too many posts.
Nobody has the time to properly look over this to give decent feedback.
Too Western?
Runty said:
Too Western?
Top portion seems fine. Those legs connect weirdly and have an odd shape below the knee.
Runty said:
Too Western?
Bad anatomy: Bad hips and legs. The thigh gap being this wide doesn't help as well. It's like the lower abdomen is not really there.
Thanks for the great work!
Konan-Beatrice said:
Thanks for the great work!
I can see nothing dealbreaking here. The unmoving checker pattern on the clothes does seem to make the torso look a bit weird at first glance and the reflection does not line up, but those are pretty minor gripes.
Thanks for the great work!
hi all, can i get some feedback on post #3661926? thought something was going for it since DFO's dev team apparently wanted this pic as a poster (scroll down a bit), but i guess i was wrong. thanks in advance
post #3666790
Does the quality of video was too low ? It was uploaded straight up from the original artist's twitter source.
freecom said:
hi all, can i get some feedback on post #3661926? thought something was going for it since DFO's dev team apparently wanted this pic as a poster (scroll down a bit), but i guess i was wrong. thanks in advance
Let's say that the source isn't what you usually see here and most, if not all, approvers don't trust unknown sources even if they're viable. We can't or don't want to check every source.
Quality-wise it's fine.
Lacrimosa said:
Let's say that the source isn't what you usually see here and most, if not all, approvers don't trust unknown sources even if they're viable. We can't or don't want to check every source.
Quality-wise it's fine.
Neople's fan art contest stuff is handled oddly, most of it is direct uploads to the official site with the artists using their in-game name and nothing even remotely close to a mirror on deviantART, pixiv or what have you. makes things a little confusing. i still haven't managed to find the artist or a more definitive source for last year's fan art contest winner (post #3240990). you'd think the dev team would at least give these people a shout out.
I assume it has to do with her neck, right?
Runty said:
I assume it has to do with her neck, right?
You're absolutely right. though the way the legs look might have also been a lesser factor.
Someone care to identify why these were deleted?
post #3469287
post #3533361
post #3507044
Proportions and anatomy are fine, quality is very high.
SciFi said:
Someone care to identify why these were deleted?
post #3469287
post #3533361
post #3507044
Proportions and anatomy are fine, quality is very high.
Art style looks too western, I guess.