Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

zetsubousensei said:

So uhh, I'm pretty new to uploading on Danbooru. I've been a member on a couple other boorus before but none with a approval system and I'm a little bit confused why some of the stuff I uploaded was rejected especially compared to something I uploaded a while ago.
I favor official art, and I saw a bunch of art by Clamp for X that hadn't been uploaded yet on other good boorus so I figured I'd upload them here.
post #3393535
post #3393374
post #3393569
post #3393650
There were nine total deleted but these are the ones I am most upset over since they are of high quality for a scan and don't violate any of the guidelines in the slightest.
I'm even more confused because one of the only other things I have uploaded is a scan of much lower quality.
post #3109800
Why were these rejected but not that one? Sorry if there is a really obvious reason, despite the fact that I am on here all the time I barely have any experience uploading.

I don't have problems being it a scan and it looks decent for me. The problem is more the art style. Back then it might be famous and all, but now that style quite conflicting with the current style. So most of approvers don't like it.

PhoenixG said:

I don't have problems being it a scan and it looks decent for me. The problem is more the art style. Back then it might be famous and all, but now that style quite conflicting with the current style. So most of approvers don't like it.

That kinda sucks. I wasn't aware that pre-2000s anime wasn't really welcome on this site. Guess I'll stick to uploading moeblob girls here and try a different booru for older stuff.

Squishy said:

Need the source.

If it's a scan from an artbook, "Clamp - X Infinity" won't do, you need to put the full name: "ARTBOOK X ILLUSTRATED COLLECTION 1 X INFINITY" or "ARTBOOK X ILLUSTRATED COLLECTION 2 X INFINITY" and page number where possible (refer to the last image you linked for an example of artbook source)

I don't remember being that thorough in the source when I uploaded that Kemono Friends image. I think I just had it listed as Kemono Friends Guidebook or something like that. Someone must have fixed it for me, I'll use it as a reference from now on when I upload things from physical media.

Thank you both very much. Hopefully next time I wont have any problems!

@zetsubousensei The Kemono scan features female characters. They are much likely to get approved and Danbooru has some approvers that like Kemono Friends.
Anyway, I have undeleted some of your uploads because they feature good stuff even when the artstyle is older. The age of an artstyle isn't a problem.
It's rather the source + male focus. And on top of that, it's drawn by clamp, an artist that is known to draw some...weird proportions. I'd be careful when uploading from clamp even though their stuff isn't bad.

zetsubousensei said:

I don't remember being that thorough in the source when I uploaded that Kemono Friends image. I think I just had it listed as Kemono Friends Guidebook or something like that. Someone must have fixed it for me, I'll use it as a reference from now on when I upload things from physical media.

Actually yes, someone did fix it for you as you can see in the Tag Changes.

post #3394356
post #3394313

This one was left unanswered:
post #3232961

post #3396172

post #3317656

I think these approvers are bad

PhoenixG said:

I don't have problems being it a scan and it looks decent for me. The problem is more the art style. Back then it might be famous and all, but now that style quite conflicting with the current style. So most of approvers don't like it.

they dont like it but others could like, that is wrong

tricakill said:

I think these approvers are bad

Look, you can give us posts that you think were deleted and ask for a reason as to why and maybe some will become undeleted.

I don't understand why these were deleted:

post #3399001
post #3398997

727272 said:

I don't understand why these were deleted:

post #3399001
post #3398997

Screenshots of character generators such as Custom Maid 3D 2 are hit or miss. The “art” is usually fine because it’s from a professional game, but it’s pretty generic and there’s zero artistic effort involved in such posts. Anyone who wants to look at such content can just play the game, so these screenshots aren’t that popular with most approvers. Sometimes they get approved anyway if an approver finds them particularly appealing, though.

I think the floating blue silhouettes are pretty creepy in this one, so it’s definitely on the miss side for me.

Btw, please write “post #ID” instead of pasting links; see above.

post #3404198

i somehow had a feeling it wasn't going to pass muster because of its slight sketchiness, but doesn't hurt to double check

Hey guys, I just uploaded 2 images that aren't that bad and a LOT similar and even from the same sources, WHY is it deleted? Why?

NEW_AGE_DRAGON said:

Hey guys, I just uploaded 2 images that aren't that bad and a LOT similar and even from the same sources, WHY is it deleted? Why?

Please link your posts in this thread using the "post ######" format, then we can give you feedback.

NEW_AGE_DRAGON said:

Hey guys, I just uploaded 2 images that aren't that bad and a LOT similar and even from the same sources, WHY is it deleted? Why?

HOW ABOUT YOU LINK TO THEM? … Oh, sorry, had caps on after reading your name. Anyways, like so:

post #3402401
post #3402403

Unsourced, like your other uploads, which scores you minus points, and game CGs/screencaps, which aren’t particularly popular with most approvers. I mean, just play the game.

kittey said:

HOW ABOUT YOU LINK TO THEM? … Oh, sorry, had caps on after reading your name. Anyways, like so:

post #3402401
post #3402403

Unsourced, like your other uploads, which scores you minus points, and game CGs/screencaps, which aren’t particularly popular with most approvers. I mean, just play the game.

So just the source is the problem? That's it?
I just visit the Tsuyokiss tags and there are CGs as well...Why does it have to be dirt to get it approved? I read the guidlines and all and nothing seems inappropriate...

NEW_AGE_DRAGON said:

So just the source is the problem? That's it?
I just visit the Tsuyokiss tags and there are CGs as well...Why does it have to be dirt to get it approved? I read the guidlines and all and nothing seems inappropriate...

Just a FYI, the source of your upload is supposed to be where you found the image, not the image itself that you uploaded to Danbooru.

Unbreakable said:

Just a FYI, the source of your upload is supposed to be where you found the image, not the image itself that you uploaded to Danbooru.

So can I try this again?