Alas, for it was but a lie.

More like, "The Cake is a Spy".

Cake be sappin' mah sentries?

Pic had me fooled there for a short time.

oh shi

the middle is the only thing that looks fake, and the brown thing below

PicoHan said:
the middle is the only thing that looks fake, and the brown thing below

I'd argue only the brown wrapper looks slightly off. I've seen pasties with banana fillings before and they look remarkably alike.