The pending for approval still hasn't finished so i can't update other pages. If all the posts deleted because reaching pending time limit, i don't think this pool will be complete.

@Darisce

It probably wouldn't hurt if you'd provide a proper source. If there isn't a URL to where you obtained these images, there should at least be some kind of useful description where they came from, be it a scan or game_cg or whatever. Some approvers are hesitant to touch anything that can't be traced back to where it originally came from, so you're not doing yourself any favors by only providing a filename.

As mentioned in the disapproval message, official game assets should be extracted instead of screenshot to ensure they're posted in the highest available quality and avoid issues with the game e.g. upscaling stuff or overlaying other assets on top. This comic, for example, looks slightly upscaled.

Also, while not a strict requirement in case of official translations, it's best to upload comics in the original language as it makes it easier to verify the translation is correct and potentially fix it via notes in case it's not. also it gives people choice to read in the original language if they don't like reading translated stuff.

If you manage to extract the assets, you could request the images to be replaced in the replacement request thread (third-party/non-web sources are eligible for replacement). It could save you from having to post the same image set twice and having a bunch of deletions.

iridescent_slime said:

@Darisce

It probably wouldn't hurt if you'd provide a proper source. If there isn't a URL to where you obtained these images, there should at least be some kind of useful description where they came from, be it a scan or game_cg or whatever. Some approvers are hesitant to touch anything that can't be traced back to where it originally came from, so you're not doing yourself any favors by only providing a filename.

it's a comic from mini event comic, which you gather item to open page by page, in game LostWord so does it count as game_cg?

ehh said:

As mentioned in the disapproval message, official game assets should be extracted instead of screenshot to ensure they're posted in the highest available quality and avoid issues with the game e.g. upscaling stuff or overlaying other assets on top. This comic, for example, looks slightly upscaled.

Also, while not a strict requirement in case of official translations, it's best to upload comics in the original language as it makes it easier to verify the translation is correct and potentially fix it via notes in case it's not. also it gives people choice to read in the original language if they don't like reading translated stuff.

If you manage to extract the assets, you could request the images to be replaced in the replacement request thread (third-party/non-web sources are eligible for replacement). It could save you from having to post the same image set twice and having a bunch of deletions.

They're from mobile game so in don't know if i can gather assets there, and this is the original translation for global server.