blindVigil said:
I already addressed some of these points in my last post (maybe you started composing your post before I sent mine), but just to be clear, I argued in favor of rating it Q because I overestimated where the line was drawn, not because I can't see nuance. I specifically stated I thought it was close to borderline. Also, the example posts I gave also have the tag, yet I did not at any point change their ratings. I would not have deliberately skipped those posts if I were treating the guidelines as ironclad rules.
If it's largely accepted that these posts are S because they are far more romantic than sexual (though calling hands on breasts acceptable for family friendly movie posters is kind of laughable), that's perfectly fine. I can adjust how I rate things just like I have many times before. Just remember that everyone will have a different idea of what "common sense" is and some may need to adjust in different ways than others.