Upload Feedback Thread - post here if your uploads keep getting deleted

BUR #39364 has been approved by @WRS.

create alias dongkas -> dokari

Rebrand.

The bulk update request #39364 (forum #344699) has been approved by @WRS.

Oh fuck, wrong topic.

Could someone explain why post #9033326 didn't get approved even if the same image from post #9034742 from a different site did?

Anominator said:

Could someone explain why post #9033326 didn't get approved even if the same image from post #9034742 from a different site did?

post #9034742 was uploaded by a Contributor and thus skipped the modqueue.

post #4616271

Its years old but it seems to be a perfectly good datamine and is aligned with its siblings/parent

WoodyTheFemboy said:

Not my own, but any reasons why these images were not approved?

post #8797729
post #8514969

Any reasons why these were rejected?

post #9036387
post #8986804 (rechecked by only 6 approvers)
post #8514969

post #9027641
post #9030830
post #9033901 (Approved sibling)
post #9036925 (Only checked by 5 approvers)
post #9042095 (Approved parent and sibling)
post #9044048 (Only checked by 4 approvers)

ChikaP said:

post #9034742 was uploaded by a Contributor and thus skipped the modqueue.

Thanks for the answer. Should I try and appeal then?

Anominator said:

Thanks for the answer. Should I try and appeal then?

The version you uploaded is of a lower resolution (1146x2048 versus 2260x4041), so it may be considered an "inferior" version. Thus, I don't believe it's worthwhile appealing.

post #9021209 (only 4 approvers looked at it on an appeal)

post #8995732 why it fail appeal? Got a comment on the appeal:
"The status of the artist's other works has no bearing on whether this one is approved." Ok sure but what's the issue with the image? huge breasts and gigantic breasts art being unapproved for anatomical reasons feels weak here especially considering the volume of this artists art that is posted by contributors that is comparable. I think it's fair to say.

MilkDelivery said:

post #9021209 (only 4 approvers looked at it on an appeal)

post #8995732 why it fail appeal? Got a comment on the appeal:
"The status of the artist's other works has no bearing on whether this one is approved." Ok sure but what's the issue with the image? huge breasts and gigantic breasts art being unapproved for anatomical reasons feels weak here especially considering the volume of this artists art that is posted by contributors that is comparable. I think it's fair to say.

What Contributors choose to upload has no bearing on what Approvers choose to approve.

Blank_User said:

What Contributors choose to upload has no bearing on what Approvers choose to approve.

I'm aware. But what's the limiting factors here if we cant compare to what is already up? I'd have preferred a critique of the art itself.

Hello, I'm new to contributing to this site. Why weren't these posts approved? They seem fine to me:

post #9045574
post #9045565
post #9033727
post #8998745
post #8998599

MilkDelivery said:

I'm aware. But what's the limiting factors here if we cant compare to what is already up? I'd have preferred a critique of the art itself.

Only an approver can really give feedback on the art itself, but builders and contributors can still pop in with useful advice since the approvers are often too busy to reply with anything useful. As for your new question, the two tags you want to be mindful of are 'approver:any' and 'status:deleted'. Adding the first tag will show you only posts that have gone through the modqueue and been approved, while the second will show you posts that have failed to be approved. That's not a guarantee though, and you should also pay attention to timestamps (how recently was it approved), how many different approvers have approved art by that artist, whether you're uploading E/Q art by an artist with only S/G approvals, etc.

And even with all of that, sometimes it's just not to anyone's taste despite being on-topic an high quality.

Hello. Any advice/feedback for post #9043347?

post #9045002
post #9045037
post #9045082
post #9045460
post #9046142

post #9032346 (only 7 approvers on appeal. Higher res than post #7368720 and post #9032325 got approved)

Reason? The girl is showering if the motion is the reason but idk. I'd had ugoira approved similar to this.

Hi i was wondering if i could get feedback on some posts. some are from artists with lots of approvals so i was wondering if something was off with some of them.
post #7198956
post #7120847
post #7117374
post #7964392
post #7117375

Why were these posts not approved https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts?tags=seraphu00+status%3Adeleted

Edit: Was talking to the artist on a Fate telegram and he suggested I uploaded the stuff here for sake of transparency lol, though doesn’t stop me as you’ve seen in this thread before lol