Pinging advice for post #9010606 again. Appreciate any help.
Posted under General
Pinging advice for post #9010606 again. Appreciate any help.
Witch-Hunter-Siegfried said:
Why were these posts not approved https://danbooru.donmai.us/posts?tags=seraphu00+status%3Adeleted
Edit: Was talking to the artist on a Fate telegram and he suggested I uploaded the stuff here for sake of transparency lol, though doesn’t stop me as you’ve seen in this thread before lol
Also what about this Saber of his that's been sitting in the queue for awhile too post #9056740
Art by SelinaNovaLight has been accepted before.
If post #8822610 got accepted, then why not post #9048246 and post #8875782 ?
More failed appeals I'd like to ask about, particularly given the disparity between approver vote counts shown here.
SFWpost #8933552 Thanks!
post #8934064 (only 7 approvers on appeal)
post #8934628 (only 5 approvers on appeal)post #8934993 (only 5 approvers on appeal) Thanks!post #8938350 Thanks!
Questionable
post #8813059
post #8939991
Thanks again!
Updated by andlabs
Anything, please?
How about this one?
Anyone reason why these didn't get approved? They all look well drawn to me
Updated by TheGamingRodent
coolcat1258 said:
Approved the ones I liked. A few notes on the ones I don't:
#7117374
- It has some good points but the anatomy and pose is a little odd. She's suffering from serious case of smallhands.
#7117375
- Borderline, and also with good points. It was close for me but the emphasis on the bust and the hips/thighs was a bit too exaggerated for my liking. You can try appealing this one and I think it has a shot of being approved? It entirely depends on who notices it.
TheGamingRodent said:
#9030913
- I get what it's trying to do, but the anatomy and proportions are very wonky. The coloration of the tail also makes it feel a lot more rougher that it is. Might be worth an appeal, but it might be a tough sell.
#9051311
- I like the design of the shorts, but the line work (especially the face) and pose feels a little too rough. Its decent but it doesn't reach the standards I look for in approving art.
argentb said:
#9051311
- I like the design of the shorts, but the line work (especially the face) and pose feels a little too rough. Its decent but it doesn't reach the standards I look for in approving art.
It's the artists' style for their faces (see post #7705175 for example); surely there's another reason outside of that for another chance of an approval right?
Witch-Hunter-Siegfried said:
Also what about this Saber of his that's been sitting in the queue for awhile too post #9056740
Asking again, what’s the issue with these?
Parent was approved once, so I want to see if the set could be approved again
Is there anything wrong with this pic?
Nacha said:
Don't ask for images that aren't deleted yet. This is a feedback topic for deleted images.
Being needy won't help you get something approved.
I was asking about deleted ones mainly, I was just adding it to to my question about the art of his that was deleted hence it being a reply to my earlier question
Updated by user 1164484
What was the issue with these images?
post #8996513
post #8983562
post #8975891
post #8969412
post #8965788
post #8970308 (this one was also a variant of an image that was already approved)
i don't see the issue with my most recent 9 deleted posts:
post #9050005
post #9050054
post #9050206
post #9050270
post #9052991
post #9053013
post #9053034
post #9053088
post #9053143
post #9021978
post #9021925
They are tagged, high quality and from good artists. if it's some issue outside of personal taste, i would like to know so i can improve for next time.
I want to ask any approver a question.
Someone else uploaded post #7044041 one year ago. It was not approved. Was this because of anatomy, sourcing or the cropping?
I uploaded this image straight from the source here asset #25362068 . Got it straight from senran kagura's website and this is the full image without the border being cropped. There is a set of these with other characters. Just want to know if the sourcing/cropping of the post above had any effect on the chance of approval? I do notice third party edits seem to have less chance of being approved which I understand.
Thanks
Edit: Also, would it just behoove me to ask in image replacement to replace post #7044041 with asset #25362068. It is the same image, character in the same resolution, just that they chose to crop it for some reason.
MilkDelivery said:
Edit: Also, would it just behoove me to ask in image replacement to replace post #7044041 with asset #25362068. It is the same image, character in the same resolution, just that they chose to crop it for some reason.
No, you should upload it as the parent. Read forum #164916.
Generally speaking, you should read the first post in a stickied thread before posting in it.