The Fate/Grand Retagging Project

Unbreakable said:

I still don't see why we make an exception for Archer when all the other Fate/Stay Night characters get spoiled, though I seem to be alone in thinking this.

Unlike most of the other characters whose real names are only important "in universe" because they reveal weaknesses or such, Archer's true identity is a pivotal plot point of an entire series (Unlimited Blade Works).
I don't think it'd be super dramatic if we did change his tag to keep consistent with the rest, but imo even if F/GO outright spoils his name I think he in particular should keep his tag spoiler-free. Even nowadays, not everyone who gets into Fate does so through the mobile gacha game.

BUR #4663 has been rejected.

mass update saver_(fate/prototype) -> saver_(fate)

He's not actually from Fate/Prototype, but is a prototype design...
Wouldn't a different, clearer name work better? Or nuke the tag and just have it as Arthur Pendragon (fate) + prototype?
From the quick search i made, i couldn't find any specific pixiv tag for this design.
The problem with just "fate" is that it makes a mess with saver (fate/extra).
Alternatively, the modifier could be "character material"...?

Should Craft Essences be "(fate/grand_order)" or "(fate)" for a qualifier? I'm assuming the latter since a number of FGO-specific items have been updated as such in this thread already.

And would post #4351958 be "Cook Heart" or "Cook's Heart"? I went with the former initially because that's the literal katakana pronunciation. It sounds a bit Engrishy, but I'd prefer literal over a Fandom Wiki interpretation (which they have gotten wrong on a number of occasions) in the absence of an official one.

Are we still BUR'ing/updating official romanization names?

marble_macintosh's official translation is Mable. I imagine nobody noticed because she's been at three images since before the event she's in was released in NA. I only noticed because I became briefly obsessed with her holy shit she's adorable and doubled her tag count...

BUR #4935 has been approved by @evazion.

create alias archer -> archer_(fate)

Incredibly ambiguous. As someone who has never consumed any Fate works other than Astolfo doujins, this looks like a profession tag.

Veradux said:

Are we still BUR'ing/updating official romanization names?

Yes

BUR #5006 has been approved by @evazion.

create alias marble_macintosh -> mable_macintosh

Localized name.

The bulk update request #5006 (forum #182745) has been approved by @evazion.

Man I miss when Saber just meant THE Saber. The extended Fate franchise was a mistake.

redactedclassshitposter said:

Man I miss when Saber just meant THE Saber. The extended Fate franchise was a mistake.

You and me both, brother. I can't even stand to look at any Nasu-verse franchises any more because of it, and have them black-listed in everything that supports that.

(I'm done; I'll stop shitting up the thread)

BUR #5056 has been rejected.

remove implication parvati_(fate) -> matou_sakura

She's the only "pseudo-servant with host" implication, as opposed to others that don't have them.

There's been some talk of taking the other pseudos and implicating their servant forms to their real forms.

A lot of the non-Rin ones are tagged as such already.

Post count for ganesha_(fate): 84
Post count for jinako_carigiri: 137
Post count for jinako_carigiri ganesha_(fate): 70

The most recent one, Caren, just straight up calls her Caren. I think we need to figure out tag policy on them before making/breaking implications.

BUR #5093 has been approved by @evazion.

create implication mysterious_idol_x_(alter)_(fate) -> artoria_pendragon_(all)

Let's just get this out of the way now.

Veradux said:

BUR #5093 has been approved by @evazion.

create implication mysterious_idol_x_(alter)_(fate) -> artoria_pendragon_(all)

Let's just get this out of the way now.

I think that Idol X Alter should just straight up imply artoria_pendragon_(all) instead of this roundabout method. Or do you also want MHXA and MHXX imply MHX, and Artoria Rider Alter imply Saber Alter, and Saber Alter imply Saber, etc etc?

create implication mysterious_idol_x_(alter)_(fate) -> artoria_pendragon_(all)

bunkhead said:

I think that Idol X Alter should just straight up imply artoria_pendragon_(all) instead of this roundabout method. Or do you also want MHXA and MHXX imply MHX, and Artoria Rider Alter imply Saber Alter, and Saber Alter imply Saber, etc etc?

I was mistakenly under the impression that they already did. A casual glance at the new character before making that BUR showed people tagging all three so I made an ass out of you and me by assuming. I was mistaken.

Editing time.

There're a few examples, only a couple dozen each, of people manually tagging solo pics of them that way. Probably need some minor clean up, then.

The bulk update request #5093 (forum #183241) has been approved by @evazion.

Yes, it should be a flat hierarchy. It should be this:

• Artoria Pendragon (all)
• Saber
• Saber Alter
• Santa Alter
• Saber Lily
• Saber Lion
• Sader
• Saver
• Arthur Pendragon
• Artoria Pendragon (Caster)
• Artoria Pendragon (Lancer)
• Artoria Pendragon (Lancer Alter)
• Artoria Pendragon (Swimsuit Ruler)
• Artoria Pendragon (Swimsuit Archer)
• Master Artoria
• Mysterious Heroine X
• Mysterious Heroine X (Alter)
• Mysterious Heroine XX
• Mysterious Idol X (Alter)
• Ultra Heroine Z

Not this:

• Artoria Pendragon (all)
• Saber
• Saber Alter
• Santa Alter
• Saber Lily
• Saber Lion
• Sader
• Saver
• Arthur Pendragon
• Artoria Pendragon (Caster)
• Artoria Pendragon (Lancer)
• Artoria Pendragon (Lancer Alter)
• Artoria Pendragon (Swimsuit Ruler)
• Artoria Pendragon (Swimsuit Archer)
• Master Artoria
• Mysterious Heroine X
• Mysterious Heroine X (Alter)
• Mysterious Heroine XX
• Mysterious Idol X (Alter)
• Ultra Heroine Z

The bulk update request #4935 (forum #182271) has been approved by @evazion.

This bulk update request has been rejected because it was not approved within 60 days.

The bulk update request #4621 (forum #180168) has been rejected by @DanbooruBot.